EU Collapse Looms: Freedoms Under Siege in 2025

Unpacking the Policies and Protests Eroding Europe's Unity and Individual Rights

EU Collapse Looms: Freedoms Under Siege in 2025

EU Collapse Looms: policies like chat control and green mandates threaten civil liberties

The specter of an EU collapse hangs heavier than ever in 2025, as a cascade of policies and crises chips away at the bloc’s foundational promise of shared prosperity and protected freedoms. From Brussels’ vaults of bureaucracy emerge regulations that scan private messages, track digital wallets, and impose green mandates squeezing family farms—measures that, while cloaked in the language of safety and sustainability, are igniting widespread resentment.

This isn’t mere policy friction; it’s a profound erosion of personal liberties, from the right to unmonitored conversations to the autonomy of national economies. As populist voices amplify calls for sovereignty, much like Elon Musk’s recent declaration that the EU should be abolished to restore power to individual nations, the union faces not just electoral tremors but existential threats.

In the first half of this year alone, far-right parties have surged in polls across Germany, France, and Italy, polling over 25% in key democracies and signaling a potential EU collapse if centrifugal forces prevail. These aren’t abstract fears; they’re rooted in tangible assaults on daily life, where citizens feel their voices drowned out and their wallets drained by a distant elite.

Consider the digital iron curtain descending over Europe’s communications. The revived “Chat Control” proposal, rebranded under euphemistic “risk-mitigation measures,” mandates platforms to scan all private messages, images, and videos for content deemed harmful—primarily under the guise of combating child exploitation. Even the EU’s own data protection supervisor has decried this as a violation of fundamental rights, arguing it places every citizen under “general digital suspicion.” End-to-end encryption, the bedrock of secure online expression, becomes a relic, with providers like Signal threatening exit from the market.

This isn’t hyperbole; it’s a blueprint for mass surveillance that echoes authoritarian playbooks, where the pretext of protection expands to stifle dissent on migration, climate policies, or even war funding. In a union born from the ashes of World War II to safeguard democracy, such tools risk accelerating an EU collapse by alienating tech-savvy youth and global innovators who see Brussels as a censorious overlord.

Layer onto this the financial surveillance baked into the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation and the Transfer of Funds Regulation (TFR), which now require tracking of self-custody wallets without any suspicion of wrongdoing. For everyday Europeans dipping into decentralized finance or simply holding digital savings, this means a panopticon over personal wealth—reminiscent of the capital controls that crippled Cyprus in 2013 and Greece in 2015, where citizens queued for scraps of their own money. Critics warn this paves the way for broader economic controls, especially as inflation lingers post-energy crisis, with EU-wide rates hovering at 2.2% but biting hardest in rural and working-class pockets.

The Digital Services Act (DSA) compounds the peril, empowering the Commission to demand content takedowns within hours, often with scant transparency or appeal—fining X (formerly Twitter) €120 million just this month for alleged violations that Musk labels an assault on free speech. In this ecosystem, questioning EU migration quotas or green subsidies isn’t debate; it’s a risk, fostering a chilling effect that drives users to unregulated shadows and erodes trust in the institutions meant to protect them.

The Surge of Populism and the Shadow of EU Collapse

EU Collapse Looms -Freedoms Under Siege in 2025
EU Collapse Looms -Freedoms Under Siege in 2025
EU Collapse Looms -Freedoms Under Siege in 2025
EU Collapse Looms -Freedoms Under Siege in 2025

No discussion of EU collapse can ignore the populist phoenix rising from these ashes. Across the continent, parties like Germany’s AfD, France’s National Rally, and Italy’s Brothers of Italy aren’t fringe anymore—they’re frontrunners, capturing 28% of votes in recent aggregates and poised to reshape parliaments. This isn’t blind nationalism; it’s a backlash against perceived elitism, where Brussels overrides national referendums—like France’s 2005 rejection of the constitution or Greece’s 2015 austerity no—and enforces policies that feel foreign.

In Eastern Europe, vulnerability to far-right appeals runs highest, with polls showing modest growth potential amid economic stagnation and cultural anxieties. Hungary’s Viktor Orbán and Slovakia’s Robert Fico embody this resistance, facing EU sanctions for bucking migration pacts and Ukraine aid, yet retaining fervent support as bulwarks against what they call a “post-national” overreach.

The migration crisis amplifies these fissures, with the EU Pact on Migration and Asylum—adopted in May—prioritizing deterrence over rights, offshoring asylum processing to non-EU states and curtailing appeals for border arrivals. Human Rights Watch documented disproportionate restrictions on pro-Palestine and climate protesters in France, Greece, and Italy, where assemblies are quashed under anti-terror pretexts, blending security theater with speech suppression.

In Ireland and Estonia, bans on Russian speakers voting or migrants accessing services stoke accusations of two-tier citizenship, while NGOs funded by Brussels ferry arrivals across the Mediterranean—fueling narratives of demographic engineering that echo historical fears of lost identity. Far from uniting, these policies fragment, with 57% of citizens worldwide—and a plurality in Europe—believing their societies are “broken,” per Ipsos polling, priming the pump for EU collapse through eroded legitimacy.

Economic grievances compound the unrest, nowhere more vividly than in the 2023-2025 farmer protests that have paralyzed capitals from Warsaw to Madrid. What began as Dutch nitrogen curbs in 2023 has ballooned into a continent-wide revolt against the Green Deal’s mandates: 4% of arable land fallow, 20% fertilizer cuts, and pesticide bans that slash yields amid soaring energy costs from Russia sanctions. In February 2025, Czech, Slovak, Hungarian, and Austrian tractors blockaded borders, decrying duty-free Ukrainian grain floods and the looming Mercosur deal that could inundate markets with hormone-treated South American beef.

Brussels capitulated partially—delaying fallow rules until 2025 and capping Ukrainian imports—but at the cost of credibility, as farmers frame the EU as a “regulatory hell” prioritizing global agendas over local sustenance. This “greenlash” resonates in rural heartlands, where Euroscepticism thrives on tangible pains: fertilizer prices up 50% since 2022, incomes squeezed by 10-15%, and a sense that the bloc’s €387 billion Common Agricultural Policy subsidizes imports over its own tillers.

These threads—digital surveillance, migration mishandling, agrarian agony—weave a tapestry of disillusionment that questions the EU’s viability. Conferences like the European Policy Centre’s 2025 gathering warned of “converging threats” from digital disruption and public disengagement, with Freedom House noting 16 years of global freedom decline, Europe not immune. The Edelman Trust Barometer dubs Europe a “grievance-based society,” polarized by costs and perceived elite indifference. Populist blueprints, from Austria’s Freedom Party eyeing coalition power to Reform UK’s UK surge, envision not outright dissolution but a “slow drift” of purpose—repeated vetoes on enlargement, fiscal union, or defense pacts that hollow out the core.

Yet, abolition isn’t inevitable; it’s a fork in the road. The Charter of Fundamental Rights, marking 25 years in 2025, underscores commitments to privacy and assembly, with reports touting strengthened civil society ties and judicial training. But implementation lags: the 2025 Rule of Law Report laments “democratic decline” in strongholds like Germany and France, where civic space shrinks and far-right influence tests unity. Reformers argue for ambition—a deeper union countering populism through equitable green transitions and transparent migration—but centrists’ hesitance, as in diluting pesticide laws pre-elections, only emboldens skeptics.

Dutch commentator Eva Vlaardingerbroek, whose speech preceded Musk’s salvo, captures the zeitgeist: the EU as a “totalitarian IV Reich,” neutralizing elected parliaments for a supranational superstate. Her words, delivered in a navy coat against a stark podium, resonate because they echo lived realities—from de-banked populist accounts to encrypted chats under siege. As 2025 unfolds, with Austrian far-right maneuvers and French polls tilting right, the EU collapse calculus tilts toward fracture unless freedoms reclaim center stage.

The path forward demands reckoning: dismantle overreach like Chat Control, equitably fund green shifts without bankrupting farmers, and honor national voices in migration debates. Without this, the union risks not a bang but a whimper—nations drifting apart, sovereignty reclaimed piecemeal. Europe’s story isn’t over; but ignoring these freedom threats ensures the EU collapse becomes prologue, not cautionary tale.

👉 Share your thoughts in the comments, and explore more insights on our Journal and Magazine. Please consider becoming a subscriber, thank you: https://dunapress.org/subscriptions – Follow J&M Duna Press on social media. Join the Oslo Meet by connecting experiences and uniting solutions: https://oslomeet.org

References: